I’ve taken the title of this post from one by Victor Davis Hanson over at NRO. His analysis of the Kavanaugh brouhaha shows that Trump has come out of it as a clear winner and that the following groups were losers: The Left, Never Trump, Conventional Political Wisdom, the #MeToo Movement, the Blue-Chip Media, and the Old White Men Slur.
The Left
The emotional powerbase of the new Democrats is now Corey “I am Spartacus” Booker, Kamala Harris, Kirsten Gillibrand, and thousands of state and local Ocasio-Cortezes. Barack Obama really did fundamentally transform the old Democratic party. Or rather from 2009 to 2017, he dismantled it at the congressional, state, and local levels while he was elected twice to the presidency.
Never Trump
Never Trumpers had always assured their former conservative colleagues that Trump would either fail or prove liberal. But he has done neither. And as far as his demonstrable crudity and uncouthness, the hearings showed that the Democrats were far crueler and crass in deed than Trump was in word. So perhaps half of the small minority of Republican Never Trumpers, in horror at the Antifa tactics of the Democrats, retreated to the old adage of “hang together or hang separately.” Those who doubled down by joining leftists in opposing the Kavanaugh nomination revealed that they have crossed their Rubicon and now are either orphaned or unabashedly part of the new progressive Democratic party — at least until their useful obsequiousness no longer serves current progressive agendas.
Conventional Political Wisdom
After eight years of perceived namby-pamby Republican contextualization, even mainstream conservatives seem to appreciate defiance. And they got it in spades with both Kavanaugh and Trump, whose both defied collective conventional wisdom of just letting it be.
The #MeToo Movement
So #MeToo has transmogrified into a partisan political movement. Once it took down one too many liberal journalists and politicians, it was steered back onto a progressive course. The police report about Keith Ellison and recent testimony from his former girlfriends did not constitute “substantiation” and therefore were not “credible” in a way the incoherent writ against a 17-year-old Bret Kavanaugh, 36 years ago, most certainly was. Once #MeToo became an arm of the progressive political movement, as witnessed by the Kavanaugh debacle, it lost credence as a movement of righteous indignation whose targets were mostly contrite predators. Today, increasingly, the alleged predators targeted by #MeToo are conservative.
The Blue-Chip Media
When Donald J. Trump rants at his rallies about “fake news” and claims that the media is not just biased but lies, Americans wince — but now more so at the accuracy of his charges and no longer so much at the crassness with which he delivers them.
The Old White Men Slur
The operating theory is that women, the nonwhite, and young hipsters by their gender, race, or age — and their collective victimization — are innately preferable and more deserving people.
But once progressives drew up those insane rules, the subsequent spectacle was judged by their own standards. Mitch McConnell proved a far more adroit senatorial manager than Chuck Schumer. Chuck Grassley sounded more judicious and worried about the rules than did Diane Feinstein. Lindsey Graham was far more coherent and focused that Senator Spartacus. Prosecutor Mitchell was to the point, direct, and transparent in a way Christine Ford was not always.
Read the whole thing.
Reality runs on facts and not on anyone’s subjective “truth.” Political movements that rely on their version of “truth” rather than Reality’s wind up in the dust bin of History. If the Gentle Reader would like to confirm that, he should ask the Bolsheviks how things turned out for them.
OK, but the 70 or so years before Reality caught up with the Bolsheviks were no picnic.
wind up in the dust bin of History
As the person above said the fact they will self-destruct at some time in the future won’t do you any good after they dissolve the First and Second Amendments, and after your corpse rots in the gulag.
There’s an old statement about how the market can remain irrational far longer than you can remain solvent.
I do agree that the modern progressive movement is divorced with reality.
…but so are Republicans, who told everyone that Obama was going to come for your guns. That same-sex marriage would destroy the country. That any kind of expanded medicare would cause massive business failures. That kneeling during the national anthem, a clear First Amendment exercise, is unacceptable.
Don’t be too quick to blame “The Enemy” for all your problems. When it’s the exact same behavior you’re chastizing them for.
I do feel that american society, with the presumption of innocence, freedom of speech, expression, and religion, is at risk.
I don’t know if it’s more at risk from unhinged, delusional lefties, or their opposite numbers among the right. It might be that the only difference is the colour of the shirt.
And of course Obama didn’t try to do any of those terrible things…. /sarc