When the next edition of Black’s Law Dictionary comes out, the editors should put a copy of this next to the definition of overbroad subpoena.
BTW, The Dread Pro-Se Kimberlin’s subpoena served on me in the same case was also overbroad, but I didn’t bother objecting because I didn’t have what he was fishing for.
OTOH, three years worth of email, provided on paper, sorted by checksum, would keep the diddler busy for quite a while.
I’m pretty sure that nobody would respond to a subpoena for a large quantity of e-mail by printing all the e-mails out on paper, unless they happened to be running for the Democratic presidential nomination.
You dam right I would, if it is good enough for Hillary it’s good enough for everyone.
Yeah, that’s a fishing expedition, and I’m not even good at IANAL law.
The little child molest or didn’t realize he would have gotten a substantial bill for that subpoena obviously. But of course, no judge would ever permit that dubpoena.
Going after a prosecutor with a subpoena on a fishing expedition. Not going to fly with any judge.
I’d have printed them out. In Comic Sans.
Print them out in wingdings.
He’s probably fluent in wingdings.
Print on colored paper. With ink almost a match.
“All emails stored on your servers…”
I’d comply to the letter and turn over all emails stored on MY servers for my gmail account… a grand total of 0… that’s kind of the point of a web-based email account isn’t it?
NM, I thought this was addressed to Frey.
Probably cheaper for Google to just hit search, then send the file in. Compared to even having a discussion with a lawyer about if the request is over broad. Whats the going rate for emails these days, $1 per item turned over.
It’s addressed to Google.
But the Production box is not checked.
I wonder if that’s why the clerk didn’t sign and date it.
Seems to have the same problem with checking the box on green cards for some reason. What is it with this guy that he JUST. CAN’T. FOLLOW. RULES?
After all, laws ARE for the little people, right? 😉
Better than the one that was filed by Bill for Doug. It just says “all.”
*snort*
LOL!
Another member of The Team seems to think he has a right to demand anything:
https://twitter.com/DeepBrainRadio/status/676249662186233856
This demand has been answered many times. If he wasn’t suffering from dementia, and didn’t erase his ravings regularly, he would be able to find the answers. He is merely trying to use everyone for his litigation prep. Let’s not help him.
It would seem intuitively obvious that the list
“1) Gail Schmalfeldt”
would suffice. Any additional names would be icing on cake.
“But Judge if you’d just let me issue subpoenas like a lawyer things would go quicker. I’ll be good I promise!”
I guess BK just proved to the judge his disinclination to extend the courtesy to Kimberlin was wise.
These guys have threatened subpoenas forever.
s