Dread Pirate #BrettKimberlin Post of the Day


Brett Kimberlin (aka Dread Pirate Kimberlin) has been engaging in lawfare by bringing frivolous legal action against people who have the effrontery to write the truth about him and his background. Fortunately, some of the folks Mr. Kimberlin has gone after are pushing back. Of course, he views this as unfair. He reminds me of a bully who whines when he gets hit back.

The most vigorous pushback is coming from Aaron Walker who is suing Mr. Kimberlin in both Virginia and federal courts. Mr. Kimberlin has made it clear that he does not intend to cooperate with discovery in these cases. On Tuesday, I posted the Motion to Compel Discovery filed by Mr. Walker’s lawyer Dan Backer in the Virginia case. It referred to several exhibits. Yesterday, we looked at Exhibits A through D. Exhibit E consists of Certified Mail Receipts. Let’s skip that and go to Exhibits F through K.

Exhibits F through J are emails recording an exchange between Dan Backer and Brett Kimberlin over whether or not Mr. Kimberlin will meet his obligations in the discovery process. Note that the top part of each Exhibit is a new email and that all or part of a previous email may be seen at the bottom. Note also that I have redacted Mr. Kimberlin’s email address.

In Exhibit F Brett Kimberlin informs Dan Backer that he will not reply to the discovery in a timely manner.

In Exhibit G Mr. Backer reminds Mr. Kimberlin of the upcoming due date and offers extra time if needed.

In Exhibit H Brett Kimberlin replies that he views the case as frivolous and suggests that Dan Backer “review the rules on sanctions prior to proceeding with this case.”

In Exhibit I Mr. Blocker offers to work with Brett Kimberlin on a joint motion to ask the court to resolve their impasse.

In Exhibit J Mr. Kimberlin claims that his 15 December date to file a Motion for Sanctions, a Motion to Dismiss, and a Motion for Protective Order Is justified because he is “cooperating with the FBI and other law enforcement agencies on several issues involving your client.” He asserts that no judge is going to force him to participate in discovery. He wraps everything in his claim that he is being harassed.

Exhibit K is a copy of a post by Patrick Frey (of Patterico’s Pontifications) concerning an email he says he received from Brett Kimberlin. If properly authenticated, it would tend to demonstrate a pattern of behavior on Mr. Kimberlin’s part regarding claims of harassment and defamation and also of threats to use the courts as a blunt instrument through lawsuits against those who publish information about him.

Of course, Aaron Walker and his lawyers have called Brett Kimberlin’s bluff and have filed a Motion to Compel Discovery. There will be a hearing on that motion tomorrow, and tomorrow I’ll post information related on how Mr. Kimberlin has tried get that hearing delayed.

Stay tuned.

Tick, tick, tick, tick, …

5 thoughts on “Dread Pirate #BrettKimberlin Post of the Day

  1. I seem to remember reading that BK had gotten a law degree while in prison. If that is correct I’m surprised at the tone and style he uses, especially in his communication with Mr Backer.

    To my mind he alternates between bully boy I’m coming after you and whining poor little me, you big meanie. Surely he realizes that that is not the way to win friends or persuade, which should be his objective, people.

    At any rate you have captured my attention and I’m very interested in how this progresses.

    Looking forward to any future updates.

  2. The judge is going to seriously slam BK at Friday’s hearing, at most compel discovery. BK obviously has no intention of complying, and is just going to open himself up to get sanctioned. Backer is going above and beyond what he needs to do, and BK just keeps digging. I almost feel sorry for him at this point.

    Almost.

  3. So his argument seems to boil down to “this case is eventually going to be thrown out of court, thus I don’t need to comply with discovery”. Has that argument ever been successfully used before?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s